The Bombay High Court on Thursday stayed until November 25 the demolition of a dilapidated south Mumbai building housing a mosque and a historic rest house for Haj pilgrims, also known as underworld don Dawood Ibrahim's former residence, hours after the civic body began pulling down the structure.
But by the time the high court's order came in, some portion of the two-storey structure was already demolished by the civic authorities.
A division bench of Chief Justice Mahesh Chandra Tripathi and Justice Advait M Sethna said the matter involved highly disputed facts requiring a proper hearing and directed all parties to maintain status quo till the next date of listing.
"Let the matter stand over to Wednesday (November 25). Till the next date of listing, parties shall maintain the status quo," the bench said.
The Brihanmumbai Municipal Corporation (BMC) had begun razing the Haji Ismail Haji Habib Musafirkhana building on Pakmodia Street in the Bhendi Bazaar area on Thursday morning after classifying it under the C-1 category, which denotes "dangerous and dilapidated" structures requiring demolition.
During the post-lunch session following the court's order, the BMC's lawyer informed the bench that it would take 30 minutes to an hour to withdraw civic officials from the site.
The interim order was passed on a writ petition filed by Shaikh Abdul Razak and Amirali Vazirali Panjwani, who claimed to be interested parties and beneficiaries of the Waqf institution, Haji Ismail Haji Habib Musafirkhana Trust.
Earlier in the day, the BMC had begun razing the Haji Ismail Haji Habib Musafirkhana building and had placed its personnel at the site. Police personnel were also kept ready for any eventuality.
A civic official said four JCBs, dumpers, gas-cutters, and 80 labourers were deployed for the demolition, which started around 7 am.
As many as 680 police constables and 80 officers, including assistant commissioner and above ranks, were present at the site to avoid law and order issues, he added.
Some portion of the structure was demolished before the HC court order came in, the official said.
According to the plea, there was a 148.79-square-metre ground-floor mosque belonging to the Sunni Hanafi sect inside the Haji Ismail Haji Habib Musafirkhana building on Pakmodia Street in Bhendi Bazaar.
The plea said the property was permanently dedicated in October 1864 by Haji Miya Haji Ismail Haji Habib as a rest house for Haj pilgrims along with a mosque, a fact recorded on an Arabic and Persian marble plaque embedded in the mosque wall.
Asserting that the mosque is a public trust property "used by the general public to offer Namaz, five times a day", the petitioners objected to the BMC notice — pasted on the mosque's wall on November 17 — referring to the shrine as a "prayer hall".
The plea alleged that this terminology mirrored a disputed May 2016 sale agreement through which the trust's trustees allegedly sold the property for Rs 1.10 crore to the Saifee Burhani Upliftment Trust (SBUT) for redevelopment.
"The mischief herein lies in calling a 'Masjid' as a 'prayer hall' by the Trustees and the developer, to circumvent the law of the land, which mandates that Masjid cannot be sold, since the ownership vests in the Almighty Allah," the petition stated.
Challenging the demolition notice issued by the Executive Engineer (Building and Factory), C-Ward, on November 16, the petitioners contended that it was pasted on the building's walls on November 17 and directed occupants to vacate by November 18.
They argued that giving less than 24 hours to vacate was arbitrary and violated a Maharashtra government notification dated April 25, 2025, which mandates a minimum 15-day notice period for such evictions.
The demolition, initially scheduled for November 18, was delayed after locals opposed the short notice, and resumed on Thursday.
The petitioners further alleged that the notice was issued at the behest of the developer in "blatant violation of principles of natural justice" and disregarded a State Waqf Tribunal order as well as Supreme Court directives that had granted status quo and permission for repairs.
Seeking to quash the November 16 notice, they urged the court to restrain authorities from damaging the structure "to protect the waqf property in the interest of justice".
The BMC denied the allegations, submitting that the first notice had been issued in 2018. The civic body also told the court that while the dispute was pending before the State Waqf Tribunal, the Supreme Court had already disposed of the related matter.
The building also figures prominently in the history of underworld don Dawood Ibrahim, the mastermind of the 1993 Mumbai serial blasts, who lived there with his family in the 1970s during his rise in the city's criminal underworld before fleeing India in 1986.
After the Kaskar family moved from Temkar Mohalla to the Musafirkhana on Pakmodia Street, the building and its surrounding area not only served as the unofficial headquarters of Dawood's fledgling gang but also witnessed an assassination attempt on him when members of the rival Pathan gang opened fire at its entrance in a bid to eliminate him.
His occupancy is also recorded in legal proceedings over the property, with a March 2015 memorandum of understanding between the Musafirkhana Trust and SBUT, reproduced in a 2019 Bombay High Court judgment, noting that Dawood occupied the entire 568.87-square-foot first floor of the building.