Washington: The US Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) agency has become one of the most visible and controversial arms of President Donald Trump's immigration crackdown, with its operations increasingly drawing protests, lawsuits and confrontations with state and local authorities.
The scrutiny intensified after a series of shootings involving federal immigration officers, including the killing of Renee Good, a 37-year-old US citizen and mother of three, in Minneapolis in January.
Another US citizen, Alex Pretti, was fatally shot by federal immigration officers in Minneapolis later that month. Importantly, Pretti was shot by US Border Patrol agents, not ICE officers. Both incidents occurred during the wider federal immigration enforcement operation in Minnesota.
The shootings triggered investigations and protests, while videos recorded by bystanders challenged aspects of the federal government's initial accounts of both incidents. Reuters reported that federal authorities subsequently handed over previously withheld evidence, including body-camera footage, to Minnesota prosecutors.
The controversy has since expanded beyond shootings to include deaths in immigration detention, the treatment of children during enforcement operations, the use of masked federal agents, and disputes between federal immigration authorities and cities and states.
The US Immigration and Customs Enforcement, or ICE, is a federal agency within the Department of Homeland Security (DHS). It was created in 2003 following the restructuring of US federal agencies after the September 11, 2001 attacks.
ICE describes its mission as enforcing federal laws relating to immigration, customs and trade, including both civil and criminal enforcement. The agency has more than 20,000 law-enforcement and support personnel and operates hundreds of offices in the US and abroad, according to its own annual report.
ICE's three principal operational components are:
Enforcement and Removal Operations (ERO): Responsible for identifying, arresting, detaining and removing people who are subject to immigration enforcement.
Homeland Security Investigations (HSI): Conducts criminal investigations involving areas including human trafficking, smuggling, drug trafficking, financial crimes, cybercrime and other cross-border criminal activity.
Office of the Principal Legal Advisor (OPLA): Provides legal representation for DHS in immigration proceedings before the US Department of Justice's Executive Office for Immigration Review.
This distinction matters because not every federal immigration officer involved in the current crackdown is an ICE officer. Border Patrol, for example, belongs to US Customs and Border Protection (CBP), another DHS agency.
Trump's second administration has made large-scale immigration enforcement a central policy priority.
The administration has expanded immigration enforcement operations and increased funding for federal immigration agencies. The supplied Reuters report says the administration has budgeted $170 billion for immigration enforcement agencies through September 2029, an unprecedented level of funding.
The increased enforcement has also changed the visibility of ICE. Agents have been deployed in large numbers to cities, carried out arrests in residential areas and workplaces, and participated in operations that have generated confrontations with protesters and local officials.
Minneapolis became the centre of the national debate in late 2025 and early 2026 after the administration launched Operation Metro Surge, a large immigration enforcement operation in Minnesota.
Reuters reported that around 3,000 federal immigration agents were deployed during the operation and that ICE recorded roughly 4,000 arrests. The operation ran from December through February and left a significant political and social impact on Minneapolis and surrounding communities.
The operation also produced some of the most serious allegations against federal immigration officers.
The debate over ICE is not based on a single incident. A series of shootings, arrests and deaths has led to criminal investigations, civil litigation and demands for greater transparency.
The cases are at different stages. Some involve ongoing investigations, while others have resulted in criminal charges. Allegations against individual officers should therefore not be treated as established findings unless a court or investigation has determined them.
Renee Good — Minneapolis
On January 7, ICE officer Jonathan Ross shot and killed Renee Good, who was inside her vehicle in Minneapolis.
Federal officials said Good had attempted to run over the officer. However, Reuters reviewed and verified video footage that appeared to show her vehicle moving away from the officer when he fired. The incident became the subject of a state investigation and a wider legal debate over whether federal immigration officers can be prosecuted under state law for conduct carried out during their official duties.
Minnesota prosecutors continue to investigate the shooting. The federal government later handed over body-camera footage and other evidence to state investigators after months of dispute over access to the material.
The case has become one of the most prominent examples cited by civil-rights groups in their criticism of ICE's use of force.
Alex Pretti — Minneapolis
On January 24, Alex Pretti, another US citizen, was fatally shot during a confrontation with federal immigration officers in Minneapolis.
This was not an ICE shooting. Pretti was shot by Border Patrol agents, which is important when assessing ICE specifically.
DHS initially said Pretti had approached officers with a handgun and resisted attempts to disarm him. Bystander video reviewed by Reuters showed Pretti holding a phone during the confrontation, while Minneapolis Police Chief Brian O'Hara said Pretti legally possessed a handgun.
The shooting nevertheless became part of the wider scrutiny of the Trump administration's federal immigration operation because ICE, Border Patrol and other DHS personnel were operating together in Minneapolis.
Julio Sosa-Celis — Minneapolis
On January 14, ICE agent Christian Castro shot and wounded Venezuelan national Julio Cesar Sosa-Celis during Operation Metro Surge.
Castro initially told investigators that he had fired after Sosa-Celis and another man attacked him with a broom and snow shovel.
Prosecutors later said video evidence contradicted that account and showed Castro firing through the front door of Sosa-Celis' apartment while standing outside. The bullet struck Sosa-Celis in the leg and lodged in the wall of a child's bedroom, prosecutors said.
Castro has pleaded not guilty to federal charges of making materially false statements. He also faces Minnesota charges including second-degree assault and falsely reporting a crime. ICE has suspended him without pay.
The case is particularly significant because Castro became the first federal law-enforcement officer to face a US Justice Department prosecution for alleged wrongdoing arising from Operation Metro Surge, according to Reuters.
Lorenzo Salgado Araujo — Houston
In July, an ICE officer fatally shot Lorenzo Salgado Araujo during an immigration enforcement operation in Houston.
DHS said Salgado attempted to ram an immigration enforcement vehicle. The circumstances of the shooting became disputed, and the incident triggered protests and demands for greater transparency.
The Houston shooting was followed days later by another fatal shooting in Maine. Neither man was the intended target of the immigration operation that led to the encounters, according to Reuters' reporting.
Johan Sebastian Duran — Maine
In July, an ICE officer fatally shot Johan Sebastian Duran, a Colombian national, during a vehicle stop in Biddeford, Maine.
Reuters reported that Duran was not the target of the immigration operation and that immigration advocates said he was authorised to work in the US.
Federal authorities did not initially provide evidence supporting their account that Duran posed a threat that justified the use of deadly force. The Maine Attorney General's Office opened an investigation. Witnesses described seeing the vehicle encounter and its aftermath.
The shootings in Houston and Maine led ICE to temporarily suspend most vehicle stops nationwide. Border czar Tom Homan described the measure as a temporary pause.
Wilber Rafael Garces Perez — Austin
The latest major case came in Austin, Texas, on September 20.
An ICE officer shot and wounded Wilber Rafael Garces Perez, a 28-year-old Venezuelan man. He was initially hospitalised in serious but stable condition and was subsequently taken into ICE custody. DHS said Perez was in the US illegally and was subject to a final removal order. His lawyer disputed aspects of that account.
The circumstances of the shooting remain disputed.
Perez said on September 21 that he had been working as a delivery driver and that a vehicle connected to immigration officers had sideswiped his car. He said he was shot while still in the vehicle and had a bullet lodged in his back. Austin police, however, said he fled on foot. DHS has not publicly provided a detailed account of the shooting.
Austin Mayor Kirk Watson has called for city police and the Texas Rangers to participate in the investigation rather than leaving the matter solely to federal immigration authorities.
The scrutiny of ICE is not limited to shootings.
According to ICE data reported by Reuters in April, at least 17 people had died in US immigration custody in 2026 by early April, following 31 deaths in ICE custody in 2025 — the highest annual total in two decades. The reported causes included presumed suicides, medical emergencies and other health complications.
In some cases, families and advocates have alleged inadequate medical care. ICE has said comprehensive medical care is provided to people in its custody.
The number and circumstances of deaths have therefore become another area of scrutiny over detention conditions and the government's responsibility towards people held in immigration custody.
Another flashpoint emerged in Columbia Heights, Minnesota, during the Minneapolis operation, when federal immigration officers detained the father of a five-year-old Ecuadorian boy, Liam Conejo Ramos.
Witnesses and school officials said the child was present when agents detained his father and that the boy was subsequently taken from the scene. The Trump administration defended the operation, while the family's lawyers and local officials disputed aspects of the federal account.
The case became part of the broader debate over how immigration enforcement should be conducted when children are present.
Civil-rights and migrant-rights organisations have raised concerns about several aspects of the expanded immigration operation, including:
Human Rights Watch, for example, said its review of video footage from the Renee Good shooting did not support the federal government's initial description of Good as posing a lethal threat. That is the assessment of the organisation and not a court finding.
The wider question is therefore not simply whether ICE has the legal authority to enforce immigration laws. It is also how that authority is exercised and what legal and constitutional limits apply when officers use force, enter communities or detain people.
Resistance to ICE is taking several forms across the US. It is important, however, not to describe all of these jurisdictions as simply being "against ICE". Their policies differ and are often framed around the division of federal and local powers.
Minneapolis
Minneapolis became one of the most prominent centres of resistance during Operation Metro Surge.
Mayor Jacob Frey defended city policies limiting local police involvement in federal immigration enforcement. He said Minneapolis police would cooperate with federal authorities in ordinary criminal investigations but not participate directly in immigration enforcement. Reuters reported that local officials also urged residents to document federal immigration operations.
The city later prohibited agencies from using city-owned parking lots, garages and other municipal property to stage immigration enforcement operations.
Denver
Denver, Colorado, went further in February.
Mayor Mike Johnston issued an executive order directing city police to protect peaceful protesters during federal immigration operations and barring ICE from using city property.
The order also said Denver law-enforcement officers would intervene if ICE agents used excessive force against residents.
This is one of the clearest examples of a local police department being directed to protect protesters and potentially intervene in an encounter involving ICE, although the order does not amount to the police department opposing federal immigration enforcement as a whole.
Portland
Portland, Oregon, has long maintained policies restricting local police involvement in federal immigration enforcement.
The Portland Police Bureau says it does not enforce federal immigration law and does not participate in ICE's 287(g) programme, which allows certain state and local officers to perform specified immigration-enforcement functions under federal supervision.
At the same time, Portland police say they can cooperate with federal agencies on ordinary criminal investigations and are not authorised to obstruct lawful federal operations.
Philadelphia
Philadelphia adopted an "ICE Out" package that sought to impose requirements on federal immigration officers, including restrictions on masks and requirements for visible identification and marked vehicles.
A federal judge subsequently blocked the city from enforcing key parts of the law against federal officers, ruling that a municipality could not dictate how federal law-enforcement agencies conduct their operations.
The Philadelphia case illustrates an important limit on local resistance: cities may adopt policies governing their own employees and property, but federal supremacy can prevent them from directly regulating federal officers.
There is no evidence of a state or federal security force formally opposing ICE as an institution or attempting to take over its immigration-enforcement role.
There are, however, examples of local police departments being directed not to assist ICE or being authorised to intervene in specific circumstances.
Denver is the clearest example among the cases documented above. Its mayor directed city police to protect peaceful protesters and said officers should intervene if ICE agents used excessive force.
Minneapolis police have also said they would respond when public safety was threatened, even while the city maintained restrictions on directly assisting federal immigration enforcement. During the January unrest, Mayor Frey said city police had intervened when the safety of people was compromised.
This is different from police forces physically confronting ICE or refusing to recognise federal authority.
The conflict is primarily over cooperation, jurisdiction and the use of local resources, rather than a formal split between two competing security forces.
The disputes have increasingly moved into federal courts.
One important issue is whether states and municipalities can impose their own restrictions on federal immigration officers.
Philadelphia's attempt to regulate masked federal officers was blocked by a federal judge, who said the city could not directly regulate how federal law-enforcement agencies operate. Similar litigation has emerged elsewhere over attempts to restrict masks or identification requirements for federal officers.
Another legal question concerns the ability of states to investigate and prosecute federal immigration officers.
The Renee Good and Alex Pretti shootings have prompted a dispute between Minnesota and the federal government over investigative authority and possible state prosecution. Reuters reported that federal officials initially argued that the officers involved were protected from state prosecution, while Minnesota prosecutors continued their investigations.
The Christian Castro case provides a particularly important development because a federal ICE officer is now facing both state and federal charges arising from an immigration operation.
ICE's legal authority to enforce immigration law is not itself new. What has changed is the scale and visibility of enforcement under the Trump administration's second-term immigration policy.
The agency is now operating amid:
The central debate is therefore broader than whether the US should enforce its immigration laws.
It concerns where the limits of federal immigration enforcement lie, how much force officers can use, what protections people encounter by agents retain, how detention conditions are monitored, and how much authority state and local governments have to regulate or refuse cooperation with federal immigration operations.
The answers are still being shaped by investigations, prosecutions and court cases across the country.
(With inputs from Reuters | US Immigration and Customs Enforcement | Human Rights Watch | City of Portland | Reuters reporting on Minnesota, Texas, Maine, Denver and Philadelphia)