Antalya (Türkiye): Two weeks of United Nations climate negotiations in Türkiye ended without an overarching agreement on Sunday after countries failed to reach consensus on whether the final document should explicitly address fossil fuels, the main source of greenhouse gas emissions.
The talks, held under the banner of COP31 in Antalya, continued for more than 44 hours beyond their scheduled Friday conclusion. However, negotiators could not secure agreement on the main political document, known as the cover decision.
The proposed text, prepared under the joint Turkish-Australian leadership, did not explicitly mention fossil fuels or call for a transition away from coal, oil and gas. This drew objections from the European Union (EU), the United Kingdom and several other countries, which argued that the agreement failed to reflect the urgency of climate action.
Although the main agreement was not adopted, countries made progress on several smaller decisions during the conference.
The dispute centred on whether the final document should include a clear commitment to move away from fossil fuels.
At the 2023 COP28 summit in Dubai, countries had agreed to transition away from fossil fuels in energy systems. Several nations at COP31 wanted that commitment reaffirmed and strengthened through explicit language in the new agreement.
The latest draft, however, referred to the earlier Dubai agreement without directly naming fossil fuels. The EU rejected the proposal, arguing that a climate agreement could not ignore the principal driver of global warming.
The Marshall Islands, Vanuatu and Panama were among the countries that also raised objections. Several developing nations and climate-vulnerable countries called for stronger language on emissions reduction and the need to limit global warming to 1.5 degrees Celsius.
Russia opposed including explicit references to fossil fuels, arguing that reducing oil and gas supplies faster than demand could trigger price shocks and energy shortages. Saudi Arabia also opposed removing any potential solutions from the climate response, maintaining that all options should remain available.
Climate finance adds to the deadlock
Developing countries have been pressing wealthier nations to provide more predictable financial assistance to help them adapt to rising temperatures, extreme weather events and other climate-related impacts.
They also sought clearer commitments on funding for adaptation, technology transfer and support for vulnerable communities. Several delegations argued that existing financial pledges lacked sufficient detail on how the money would reach countries facing the greatest climate risks.
The draft agreement also included support for carbon capture and storage technologies. However, the proposal attracted criticism from climate campaigners and some countries, which warned that such technologies could be used to justify continued investment in fossil fuels rather than accelerate the shift to cleaner energy.
Under the UN climate negotiations process, major decisions generally require consensus among participating countries.This meant that objections from several delegations prevented the proposed cover decision from being adopted.
COP31 President Murat Kurum acknowledged that countries had failed to agree on the document and said no new text would be prepared without consensus, Reuters reported.
"We did everything we could," Kurum said, adding that existing decisions would be implemented.
The failure to adopt the overarching agreement did not mean that all negotiations ended without outcomes. Several less contentious decisions were agreed upon, although the central disagreements over fossil fuels, climate finance and the pace of the energy transition remained unresolved.
The outcome leaves these issues for further negotiations at the next UN climate conference, scheduled to take place in Addis Ababa, Ethiopia, in November 2027.
(With agency inputs)