Mumbai: Former Tata Trusts trustee and senior advocate Darius J Khambata has accused Vice-Chairmen Venu Srinivasan and Vijay Singh of reversing their position on the proposed listing of Tata Sons without consulting fellow trustees, and selectively invoking resolutions to question his conduct.
In a strongly worded letter dated November 17, seen by ANI, Khambata responded to the duo's November 11 letter, rejecting their allegations and questioning their own adherence to resolutions concerning trustee reappointments and changes in the trusts' composition.
The exchange is part of an escalating dispute within Tata Trusts over the proposed listing of Tata Sons, the interpretation of trustee resolutions and the events leading to the Tata Sons board's September 17, 2026 decision on its leadership.
Khambata questioned why Srinivasan and Singh changed their position on listing in April 2026, after opposing it in March 2024, May 2025 and July 2025. He said he had consistently opposed listing while supporting a solution that would provide liquidity to the Shapoorji Pallonji Group, which holds a minority stake in Tata Sons.
Also Read:
Rejecting the vice-chairmen's argument that listing could coexist with philanthropic objectives, Khambata said their example of Novo Nordisk was misconceived, arguing that its structure was similar to that of Tata Sons and supported the case against listing.
He also challenged their criticism of his position on N Chandrasekaran's proposed third term as Tata Sons chairman. Khambata said he had supported the reappointment after being impressed by Chandrasekaran's performance figures at a July 2025 trustees' meeting and had abided by the unanimous resolution.
However, he questioned whether Srinivasan, as a Tata Trusts nominee director, had informed Tata Sons' Nomination and Remuneration Committee of the trustees' August 13, 2026 decision to respect Chandrasekaran's wish not to seek another term and begin the process of selecting a successor.
Khambata also rejected allegations that he had remained silent when trustee resolutions were not followed or had strategised to temporarily remove Srinivasan to alter the composition of Sir Dorabji Tata Trust.
He pointed out that he had voted in favour of Srinivasan's reappointment and said the appointments of Neville Tata and Bhaskar Bhatt as trustees had been unanimous.
On the October 17, 2024 resolution concerning trustee reappointments, Khambata accused Srinivasan, Singh and Tata Trusts Chairman Noel Tata of failing to honour its spirit by voting against Mehli Mistry's reappointment.
He further said he had written to fellow trustees on March 2, 2026, seeking a meeting over developments concerning Chandrasekaran's tenure, but received no response.
Khambata maintained that Tata Trusts' control over Tata Sons was central to the Tata model and formed part of trustees' fiduciary duty to protect the trusts' shareholding. He said his November 2 letter had questioned the manner in which the Tata Sons board acted on September 17, not Chandrasekaran's performance or suitability.
Concluding his response, Khambata said he was facing personal attacks for raising questions about the September 17 decision, but maintained that his conscience was clear. He also called for dialogue to resolve the differences in the interests of Tata Sons, Tata Trusts and the wider Tata Group.




